Inona's Witchery

Is Wicca a Legitimate Religion?

Home
Witch Speak
Q and A
History
Philosophy
Doctrines
Celebrations
My Writings
Links
Talk To Me
"True religion is always mild, propitious, and humble,
Plays not the tyrant, plants no faith in blood;
Nor bears destruction on her chariotwheels;
But stoops to polish, succor, and redress,
And builds her grandeur on the public good."


"Mahomet the Imposter" by James Miller 

What is "Legitimate"?

This question was answered legally in the US in 1985 when the case of Dettmer v. Landon (617F Supp 592) was decided by the District Court of Virginia. It was reaffirmed in 1986 by the Federal Appeals Court, Fourth Circuit. However, many religious leaders and some political leaders, are terribly offended by this decision. It seems that the reverence for nature and a lack of intervention between the 'flock' and the Divine has the mainstream religious community highly upset. Of course, they forget that the same First Amendment to the US Constitution that requires us to be subjected to their loudly voiced opinions also guarantees us the right to practice our form of religion, Wicca. (See "Legally Wiccan" for more information.)

I'm wondering, didn't the Christian God create all of nature first? Did he then create an intermediary to help his future creations, Adam and Eve, understand him? I could be mistaken here because I wasn't raised on three church visits a week, and the only time I remember there being a bible in our house was when my sister thought she wanted to be a nun. She later became a cocktail waitress in Las Vegas, but I digress.

Religion - an organized system of beliefs, rites, and celebrations
centered around a supernatural being.

This is only one definition of the word 'religion.' It comes from a cheap little paperback dictionary I picked up at a dollar store. I prefer this definition to some of the others I've seen because it makes it very obvious that Wicca is a religion. At this point, maybe I should give my definition of Wicca, Witchcraft, and Paganism. Although these words are used interchangeably by some, I don't use them that way when referring to the general population. I use all three when referring to myself because my particular practice includes elements of all three.

Starting with the most specific, witchcraft is a practice that may or may not have anything to do with a religious belief. It is using the latent power of the universe to affect change in your life or the life of someone that has asked you to help. Some people believe that this power is from a divine source and some think it isn't. Witchcraft can be practiced by anyone, Pagan or not.

Wicca is an earth-based religion where a goddess, a god, and nature are revered. The terms Wicca and Witchcraft are used interchangeably by most Wiccans because Gerald Gardner's basis for the religion included information from what he called the "witch religion." Some Wiccans do not use Witchcraft in their practices, claiming that they see it as a purely religious experience. The traditional approach to connecting with the Gods was through Witchcraft so separating the two seems a bit out of line to me. (See this article for more information.)

'Pagan' and 'Paganism' are words comparable to 'Christian' and 'Christianity'. These are general terms used to categorize a variety of religious beliefs. Differing Pagan belief systems are called traditions, whereas differencing Christian belief systems are called denominations. Confused yet? Basically, 'Pagan' is a blanket term used to describe a variety of different earth-based religions. 'Wicca' is one of those religions. 'Witchcraft' is a practice used by some Pagans, some Wiccans, and some non-Pagans.

Okay, back to defining Wicca as a "legitimate" religion. By using the simple definition given earlier, anyone familiar with Wicca can immediately see that it is indeed a religion. First and foremost, to be considered a legitimate religion there must be a supernatural force or being that is recognized and revered. In Wicca and most other Pagan religions, deity is regarded as an immanent (which means ever-present, or inherently a part of) force in everyday living. In striving to revere deity by imitation of actions, Wiccans see themselves and all of humanity as part of the environment, inherently connected to the natural world in which we live. This is opposed to the view of many "mainstream" religions which see deity as imminent (which means on the verge of arriving or projecting over). In revering an imminent deity, humankind is seen as above, or separate from, the natural world.

What about an organized system of beliefs, rites, and celebrations? I'll just run through these in the order they are listed. Since there is no central, governing body in charge of making decisions for all Pagans or Wiccans, it is often mistakenly assumed that there is little to no common ground among the different traditions. There is no universally accepted Pagan or Wiccan 'Bible', so how can we prove that there are commonly held beliefs? It takes a little more digging around, but eventually it is possible to set out a list of 'dogmatic statements' that most Wiccans can agree upon. Of course, some will be interpreted a bit differently by each group, but that happens quite often in mainstream religions, too. In 1974, the Council of American Witches drafted and adopted what was called "The 13 Principles of Wiccan Belief". This document represents some of the common points of Wiccan theology, but in no way is to be interpreted as the complete and final summation of the religion. (see "Doctrines" and "Philosophy" for more information.)

What about rites and celebrations? Despite the traditional variations, most of the rites and celebrations performed and observed by Pagans are organized according to nature and naturally occurring events. This makes perfect sense if you remember that deity is regarded as immanent. In Wicca, Sabbats are celebrated on the solstices, equinoxes, and mid-points between the two. Esbats are celebrated in accordance with the cycles of the moon. Rites of Passage are celebrated at important times in a person's life, whether it is a naturally occurring event like the onset of puberty or a manufactured event such as marriage. Even though the deity being celebrated or called upon may have a different name and different attributes associated with him or her, all of these celebrations have representative religious mythology which defines deity's relationship to each occurrence. Therefore, these rites and celebrations are centered around a supernatural being.

Is Wicca a religion? By using a fairly simple definition of the word to analyze the beliefs and practices of Wiccans and other Pagans, the answer is proven to be a resounding "Yes!". Coupled with legal definitions and rulings, there can be no doubt that Wiccans and other Pagans are entitled to the same considerations as any other religious group.

By Inona 2002
Last modified Nov. 2005

PLEASE NOTE: All graphics and written materials on this site are copyright © protected by myself or someone else. Unless otherwise noted, all written material on this site is my original material. Material that was not created by me is credited to its author. Graphics are credited to and obtained from the sites of the artists who created them, as far as I know. Please do not copy anything from this site, either written or graphic. Visit the creators' sites, buy or borrow their books, or visit 'research' sites and download directly from there. Always include credit and copyright info. To copy or reprint any of my original information, please contact me for permission.

Witchmoon - © Unknown: I lost the credit info
for this one in a computer crash.
Help finding its owner would be appreciated.